MRA - In The News

Energy Study Helps Homeowners Keep Cooling Costs From Going Through The Roof

JUNO BEACH, FLORIDA -- In the first study of its kind, Florida Power & Light Company (FPL) sponsored a tightly controlled test project that compared commonly used residential roofing materials to evaluate their relationship to home cooling costs.

The six identical, side-by-side, newly constructed Habitat for Humanity homes were built using various roofing materials: dark gray shingles, white shingles, white flat tile, white S-shaped tile, terra cotta S-shaped "Spanish" tile, and white metal. The homes were operated identically to ensure study accuracy. Temperature controls on the air conditioning thermostats of all the houses were set at a constant 77º F. And all six homes were studied unoccupied and occupied.

The study found that energy savings are most strongly influenced by the solar reflectance of roof materials. The study proves dark gray roofs reflect a mere eight percent of the heat associated with sunlight, while white shingle and terra cotta tile roofs reflect 25 and 34 percent, respectively. White metal and cement tile roofs provide the most dramatic results, reflecting 66 to 77 percent of the sun's energy.

"The results of the study clearly demonstrate that white, galvanized metal roofing material saves the most energy as a result of its high reflectance and superior ability to cool quickly at night," said Craig Muccio, Conservation Program Evaluation Coordinator, for FPL.

A white, galvanized metal roof should save a customer who lives in an average-size 1,770 square foot home approximately $128 or 23 percent annually in cooling costs, compared with a dark gray shingle roof on the same home. For the same size home, white, S-shaped cement tile produces the second-best savings of $110 or 20 percent of annual cooling costs followed by white, flat cement calculated at $96 per year for a 17 percent savings compared to the dark gray shingles. White shingled roofs trim $24, or about four percent off the annual cooling bill, while terra cotta S-shaped cement tiles net a modest $15, or three percent compared to dark gray shingles.

"Choosing a roof for a home, whether it's a new home or a replacement roof, is a major decision for most homeowners," Muccio said. "The purpose of this study is to provide homeowners with additional information to help them make the best, most informed decision. Every little bit we do to help our customers stay informed should ultimately conserve energy as well as save them money."


Table E-1.

Cooling Performance During Unoccupied Period July 8th 31st, 2000

Site Total
kWh
Savings
kWh
Save
Percent
Demand
kW
Savings
kW
Saved
Percent
Standard dark shingles (control home) 17.03 0.00 0.0% 1.63 0.00 ----
White "Barrel" S_tile roof 15.29 1.74 10.2% 1.44 0.19 11.80%
Standard dark shingles, sealed attic, R_19 roof deck insulation 14.73 2.30 13.5% 1.63 0.01 0.30%
Terra cotta S_tile roof 16.02 1.01 5.9% 1.57 0.06 3.70%
White "Barrel" S_tile roof 13.32 3.71 21.8% 1.07 0.56 34.20%
White flat tile roof 13.20 3.83 22.5% 1.02 0.61 37.50%
White metal roof 12.03 5.00 29.4% 0.98 0.65 39.70%


Table E-2.

Summary of Normalized Savings and Demand Reductions from Regression Estimates

Case Description Cooling Savings Peak Demand Reduction
kWh Percent kW Percent
Standard dark shingle (control) 0 0% 0
0%
White Shingle 300 4% 0.48 17%
Sealed Attic 620 9% 0.13 5%
Terra Cotta Tile 180 3% 0.36 13%
White S-Tile 1,380 20% 0.92 32%
White Flat Tile 1,200 17% 0.98 34%
White Metal 1,610 23% 0.79 28%

Back to Reflectivity: Metal's Cutting Edge

Find a contractor near your home